lightsaber duelist

[GrndAdmrlPellaeon]

Luke has gone through how many wars? Yoda only fought in one major conflict.

[Cicero]

Point taken but, the old republic jedi the accumulated knowledge of millenia on lightsaber combat while the new jedi order really had to start almost from scratch. But the polls really seem to be on g canon guys but if it wasn't limited to them I would have to pick from Kas'im, Raskta Lsu, Revan, Bane, and a few others, ohh wait I choose Tulak Hord.

[Admiral Gabriel]

yea but yoda didnt really fight.   that much.      But still YODA is the man.

[GrndAdmrlPellaeon]

Luke recovered older things things they didn't have.

[clone13538]

im torn between yoda and luke

[Watwar5]

Canon I would have to choose Yoda, he was the only one who ever came close to defeating the emperor in a straight fight (Don't know about the clones, I haven't read those books, but I'm thinking that if he was anything like the Clone Troopers and Jorus C'baoth, he wouldn't have the same experience or memory's as the original.)
Non-Canon I choose Kyle Katarn. He killed Jerec, defeated Tavion, and killed Dessan, not to mention Jerecs minions and Desanns hordes of reborn and shadow warriors. That totals to about 50-200 (I didnt count) reborn/shadow warriors, 2 and a half Sith Lords (Tavion wasn't a full sith) and atleast 7 trained Dark Jedi. That's one helluva resume.

Edit: By Canon/non-canon, I mean the movies and everything else, respectively.

[LucianoStarKiller]

post endor luke
he is considered even better than yoda and could fight young palpatine head on