Yes, that is way too small. Not in terms of population, but size. However, any decent cap ship, with good fighter management, can beat a larger ship. For the PA, for example, all you need is a Praetor, which can take some fire while its fighter load can divert the rest. (Not that having two SSDs of your own hurts, either.)
just the opposite against the SSD
your fighters, wich are diverting the fire from the ship, while your larger ones attack.
if you are carefull enough and waching out for the ships turns, you can bring down the shields without your ships get any dmg!!!
that is the reason you have to make sure your fighters stay alive!
and if u lose a fighter/bomber squadron, an another one comes out for a small period of time. this is why the Escort Carrier for!!!!
thoose small fighters additionally hard to be hit by a turbolaser
ok i have to admit it was quite alone...
just lost pesitin vs the eoth, i send this task force there and i found the reaper there lonely...